Famous Bills Legend Suggests the Bills Should Trade James Cook to the Browns for Myles Garrett

****

*Buffalo, NY – March 14, 2025* – In a surprising turn of events, a legendary figure in Buffalo Bills history has sparked a heated debate among NFL fans and analysts. Thurman Thomas, the Hall of Fame running back and cornerstone of the Bills’ iconic 1990s teams, has suggested that the Bills should consider trading rising star running back James Cook to the Cleveland Browns in exchange for defensive powerhouse Myles Garrett. The bold proposal has sent shockwaves through the NFL community, with opinions divided on whether such a move would benefit either team.

Thomas, who remains a beloved figure in Buffalo, made the suggestion during an appearance on a local sports radio show. “Look, I love James Cook. He’s a talented player, and he’s done great things for us,” Thomas said. “But if we want to take this team to the next level and finally get over that hump, we need to make some tough decisions. Myles Garrett is a game-changer on defense, and pairing him with our current roster could make us unstoppable.”

James Cook, the younger brother of Minnesota Vikings star Dalvin Cook, has emerged as a key player for the Bills over the past two seasons. Known for his speed, agility, and versatility, Cook has become a reliable weapon in Buffalo’s high-powered offense. However, Thomas believes that the Bills’ defense, while solid, lacks the dominant edge rusher needed to compete with the league’s elite teams. Myles Garrett, a perennial All-Pro and one of the most feared defensive players in the NFL, would undoubtedly fill that void.

Garrett, the first overall pick in the 2017 NFL Draft, has been a cornerstone of the Browns’ defense for nearly a decade. With his combination of size, speed, and athleticism, Garrett has consistently ranked among the league leaders in sacks and quarterback pressures. His presence on the field commands double teams and opens up opportunities for his teammates, making him a transformative player on any defense.

While the idea of acquiring Garrett is tantalizing for Bills fans, the proposed trade raises several questions. Would the Browns be willing to part with their defensive anchor? And even if they were, would the Bills be willing to sacrifice a dynamic young running back like Cook? The Browns, who have struggled to find consistency at the running back position in recent years, might view Cook as an ideal fit for their offense. However, losing Garrett would leave a massive hole in their defense, which could be difficult to fill.

NFL analysts have been quick to weigh in on the proposal. Some argue that the Bills’ offense, led by quarterback Josh Allen, is already one of the most potent in the league, and trading Cook could disrupt its rhythm. Others contend that adding a player of Garrett’s caliber would elevate the Bills’ defense to championship level, making them a more complete team. “It’s a high-risk, high-reward move,” said one analyst. “But if the Bills are serious about winning a Super Bowl, they need to consider all options.”

The Bills’ front office has remained tight-lipped about the speculation, with general manager Brandon Beane stating only that the team is “always looking for ways to improve.” Meanwhile, Browns general manager Andrew Berry has dismissed the rumors as “pure speculation,” emphasizing that Garrett is a cornerstone of the franchise.

As the NFL offseason progresses, the possibility of such a blockbuster trade remains unlikely but not impossible. For now, Bills fans can only dream of what a defense featuring Myles Garrett might look like, while Browns fans hope their star pass rusher isn’t going anywhere. One thing is certain: Thurman Thomas’ suggestion has added an intriguing layer of drama to the NFL’s offseason narrative.